Judges in Olympic determine skating is perhaps favoring their dwelling international locations.
NBC Information is reporting that they’ve knowledge that reveals judges in Olympic determine skating are biased.
In a pool of 164 judges eligible for this yr’s determine skating occasions on the video games in PyeongChang, South Korea, NBC discovered that many appear to have what might be conflicts of curiosity.
Thirty three maintain or have held management positions within the nationwide skating federations for his or her international locations and one other is an Italian decide who was sanctioned for peeking at one other decide’s scores in 2010.
NBC additionally discovered one Russian decide who has been sanctioned for violations twice, together with signaling his most popular order of end to a different decide by tapping his ft and talking to a different decide in Russian. There’s additionally one other fellow Russian decide who hugged gold medalist Adelina Sotnikova on the Sochi video games in 2014.
One other potential crimson flag is a Korean decide who informed a Korean newspaper earlier than Sochi that she would make certain skaters from her nation have been “not deprived.”
Each might find yourself judging skaters from their respective international locations on this yr’s Olympics.
Dartmouth economics professor Eric Zitzewitz studied scores from worldwide skating competitions from the final 15 years and informed NBC information he constantly discovered a measurable bias.
Zitzewitz found that in 2016 and 2017, judges added a mean of greater than three factors to skaters from their dwelling nation.
“I used to be discovering that the international locations that individuals thought have been extra corrupt in different dimensions additionally appear to have extra biased figure-skating judging,” Zitzewitz mentioned. “I’ll sound a bit of partisan as an American, however for those who kind of begin from America and go east – the nationalistic bias appears to go up.”
Prime U.S. athletes to look at on the Pyeongchang 2018 Winter Olympics
Ukraine, Russia and South Korea have been the worst offenders primarily based on Zitzewitz’s analysis.
Russia was concerned in an issue on the 2014 Olympics when Sotnikova gained.
After getting the best scores of her skating profession, she skated off the ice and proper into the arms of a Russian decide.
Many known as for an investigation after she gained and defeated the runaway favourite, South Korea’s Yuna Kim. Nevertheless, complaints have been finally denied by the Worldwide Skating Union.
Group USA Olympic uniforms by way of the years
When requested to touch upon NBC’s report, the ISU it has a “strong” process for monitoring judges, together with penalties for over-marking skaters.
“The cancellation of anonymity makes it potential to hint not solely the standard of judging,” the union mentioned, “but in addition any bias. Judges who make errors and/or are over-marking skaters obtain a warning and may be penalized by the ISU.”
The ISU additionally mentioned it was a “precedence to do its utmost to ensure a good consequence” within the PyeongChang video games.